Вот рейтинг недавний:
Upd: чёрт, не совсем недавний. Есть 2004 или 2005 года, лень искать. Там, впрочем, немногое изменилось. Сворачиваю до первых 30 по желанию общественности (не разглядел #area28, пардон), остальные по ссылке.
1 Cal Berkeley 4.96
2 Cal Tech 4.94
3 Stanford 4.87
4 Harvard 4.87
5 MIT 4.86
6 Cornell 4.55
7 Columbia 4.54
8 Illinois 4.48
9 Wisconsin 4.46
10 UCLA 4.46
11 Chicago 4.46
12 Yale 4.38
13 Texas 4.28
14 Northwestern 4.23
15 Texas A&M 4.11
16 Indiana 3.99
17 North Carolina 3.97
18 Penn State 3.95
19 Cal San Diego 3.95
20 Princeton 3.92
21 Minnesota 3.89
22 Ohio State 3.87
23 Cal San Francisco 3.86
24 Purdue 3.83
25 Penn 3.78
26 Iowa State 3.76
27 Johns Hopkins 3.74
28 Washington 3.70
29 Rice 3.70
30 Florida 3.67
рейтинги (американских) университетов и методики их расчета
рейтинги (американских) университетов и методики их расчета
Последний раз редактировалось pH<7 Ср май 31, 2006 9:11 am, всего редактировалось 2 раза.
Carpe diem
Если кому интересно вот рейтинг по непосредственно областям в химии.
Chemistry Specialties: Analytical
Ranked in 2006*
1. University of North Carolina–Chapel Hill
2. Purdue University–West Lafayette (IN)
3. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
4. University of Arizona
University of Wisconsin–Madison
6. Indiana University–Bloomington
7. University of Texas–Austin
8. University of Michigan–Ann Arbor
9. Iowa State University
10. University of Washington
11. Pennsylvania State University–University Park
12. Ohio State University
13. University of Florida
14. Florida State University
15. Louisiana State University–Baton Rouge
Michigan State University
Texas A&M University–College Station
University of Minnesota–Twin Cities
Chemistry Specialties: Biochemistry
Ranked in 2006*
1. Harvard University (MA)
2. University of California–Berkeley
3. University of California–San Francisco
4. California Institute of Technology
5. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
6. University of Wisconsin–Madison
7. Stanford University (CA)
University of California–San Diego
9. University of California–Los Angeles
10. Johns Hopkins University (MD)
Yale University (CT)
12. University of Colorado–Boulder
13. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
14. University of Washington
15. University of Michigan–Ann Arbor
16. Duke University (NC)
17. Washington University in St. Louis
Chemistry Specialties: Inorganic
Ranked in 2006*
1. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
2. California Institute of Technology
3. University of California–Berkeley
4. Northwestern University (IL)
5. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
6. Texas A&M University–College Station
7. Stanford University (CA)
8. University of Wisconsin–Madison
9. Harvard University (MA)
University of Minnesota–Twin Cities
University of North Carolina–Chapel Hill
12. University of California–San Diego
13. University of Texas–Austin
14. Cornell University (NY)
University of California–Los Angeles
University of California–Santa Barbara
University of Michigan–Ann Arbor
18. Ohio State University
University of Chicago
Chemistry Specialties: Organic
Ranked in 2006*
1. Harvard University (MA)
2. University of California–Berkeley
2. Scripps Research Institute (CA) **
3. California Institute of Technology
4. Stanford University (CA)
5. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
6. Columbia University (NY)
7. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
8. University of Wisconsin–Madison
9. University of California–Irvine
10. University of Texas–Austin
11. University of California–Los Angeles
12. University of Pennsylvania
Yale University (CT)
14. University of California–San Diego
15. Ohio State University
16. Cornell University (NY)
17. University of Chicago
Chemistry Specialties: Physical
Ranked in 2006*
1. University of California–Berkeley
2. California Institute of Technology
3. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
4. Stanford University (CA)
5. Harvard University (MA)
6. University of Chicago
7. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
8. University of Wisconsin–Madison
9. University of Colorado–Boulder
10. Columbia University (NY)
11. Northwestern University (IL)
12. University of Texas–Austin
Yale University (CT)
14. Georgia Institute of Technology
15. Cornell University (NY)
Princeton University (NJ)
University of California–Los Angeles
18. University of California–San Diego
University of California–Santa Barbara
University of Pennsylvania
21. Rice University (TX)
University of California–Irvine
Chemistry Specialties: Theoretical
Ranked in 2006*
1. University of California–Berkeley
2. California Institute of Technology
3. Columbia University (NY)
4. Harvard University (MA)
5. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Northwestern University (IL)
7. Stanford University (CA)
University of Chicago
9. University of Wisconsin–Madison
10. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
University of Texas–Austin
12. University of Georgia
Yale University (CT)
14. University of California–Los Angeles
University of Minnesota–Twin Cities
16. University of California–San Diego
University of Florida
18. Cornell University (NY)
19. Princeton University (NJ)
20. University of Pennsylvania
*This ranking was computed in January of the year cited, based on data from a survey sent out in the fall of the previous year.
Source: www.usnews.com
Chemistry Specialties: Analytical
Ranked in 2006*
1. University of North Carolina–Chapel Hill
2. Purdue University–West Lafayette (IN)
3. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
4. University of Arizona
University of Wisconsin–Madison
6. Indiana University–Bloomington
7. University of Texas–Austin
8. University of Michigan–Ann Arbor
9. Iowa State University
10. University of Washington
11. Pennsylvania State University–University Park
12. Ohio State University
13. University of Florida
14. Florida State University
15. Louisiana State University–Baton Rouge
Michigan State University
Texas A&M University–College Station
University of Minnesota–Twin Cities
Chemistry Specialties: Biochemistry
Ranked in 2006*
1. Harvard University (MA)
2. University of California–Berkeley
3. University of California–San Francisco
4. California Institute of Technology
5. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
6. University of Wisconsin–Madison
7. Stanford University (CA)
University of California–San Diego
9. University of California–Los Angeles
10. Johns Hopkins University (MD)
Yale University (CT)
12. University of Colorado–Boulder
13. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
14. University of Washington
15. University of Michigan–Ann Arbor
16. Duke University (NC)
17. Washington University in St. Louis
Chemistry Specialties: Inorganic
Ranked in 2006*
1. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
2. California Institute of Technology
3. University of California–Berkeley
4. Northwestern University (IL)
5. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
6. Texas A&M University–College Station
7. Stanford University (CA)
8. University of Wisconsin–Madison
9. Harvard University (MA)
University of Minnesota–Twin Cities
University of North Carolina–Chapel Hill
12. University of California–San Diego
13. University of Texas–Austin
14. Cornell University (NY)
University of California–Los Angeles
University of California–Santa Barbara
University of Michigan–Ann Arbor
18. Ohio State University
University of Chicago
Chemistry Specialties: Organic
Ranked in 2006*
1. Harvard University (MA)
2. University of California–Berkeley
2. Scripps Research Institute (CA) **
3. California Institute of Technology
4. Stanford University (CA)
5. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
6. Columbia University (NY)
7. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
8. University of Wisconsin–Madison
9. University of California–Irvine
10. University of Texas–Austin
11. University of California–Los Angeles
12. University of Pennsylvania
Yale University (CT)
14. University of California–San Diego
15. Ohio State University
16. Cornell University (NY)
17. University of Chicago
Chemistry Specialties: Physical
Ranked in 2006*
1. University of California–Berkeley
2. California Institute of Technology
3. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
4. Stanford University (CA)
5. Harvard University (MA)
6. University of Chicago
7. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
8. University of Wisconsin–Madison
9. University of Colorado–Boulder
10. Columbia University (NY)
11. Northwestern University (IL)
12. University of Texas–Austin
Yale University (CT)
14. Georgia Institute of Technology
15. Cornell University (NY)
Princeton University (NJ)
University of California–Los Angeles
18. University of California–San Diego
University of California–Santa Barbara
University of Pennsylvania
21. Rice University (TX)
University of California–Irvine
Chemistry Specialties: Theoretical
Ranked in 2006*
1. University of California–Berkeley
2. California Institute of Technology
3. Columbia University (NY)
4. Harvard University (MA)
5. Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Northwestern University (IL)
7. Stanford University (CA)
University of Chicago
9. University of Wisconsin–Madison
10. University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign
University of Texas–Austin
12. University of Georgia
Yale University (CT)
14. University of California–Los Angeles
University of Minnesota–Twin Cities
16. University of California–San Diego
University of Florida
18. Cornell University (NY)
19. Princeton University (NJ)
20. University of Pennsylvania
*This ranking was computed in January of the year cited, based on data from a survey sent out in the fall of the previous year.
Source: www.usnews.com
"Physics is like sex. Sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it."
---R. Feynman ---
---R. Feynman ---
pH<7 Вождь.
Я ничё не имею против против рейтингов, есть просьба: оставьте только ссылку на рейтинги, а длиннющие списки потрите, или оставьте только то что особо важно.
Как сейчас сказал один пользователь, "По ссылке я и сам могу сходить, а зачем мне видеть эту ботву на 5 экрaнов?!"
Я ничё не имею против против рейтингов, есть просьба: оставьте только ссылку на рейтинги, а длиннющие списки потрите, или оставьте только то что особо важно.
Как сейчас сказал один пользователь, "По ссылке я и сам могу сходить, а зачем мне видеть эту ботву на 5 экрaнов?!"
Последний раз редактировалось Cherep Ср май 31, 2006 3:25 am, всего редактировалось 1 раз.
Дорогой Череп, я бы с превеликим удовольствием поставил там ссылку (мне меньше шелчков копи/паст надо делать), НО: ресурс этот платный и не у всех учебных заведений есть к нему доступ, так что уж извольте мы пойдем против эстетических пожеланий "одного пользователя".
"Physics is like sex. Sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it."
---R. Feynman ---
---R. Feynman ---
Rankings of doctoral programs in the sciences are based on the results of surveys sent to academics in each discipline during the fall of 2005. The questionnaires asked individuals to rate the quality of the program at each institution on a 5-point scale: outstanding (5); strong (4); good (3); adequate (2); or marginal (1). Individuals who were unfamiliar with a particular school's programs were asked to select "don't know." Scores for each institution were totaled and divided by the number of respondents who rated that school.
Surveys in the biological sciences, chemistry, computer science, the earth sciences, mathematics, and physics were conducted by Synovate. The universe of schools surveyed consisted of schools that awarded at least five doctoral degrees according to the National Science Foundation report "Science and Engineering Doctorate Awards" for the years from 1999 through 2004. In the biological sciences, graduate programs may be offered in a university's medical school as well as its college of arts and sciences. In those cases, the medical school's program was considered separately.
Questionnaires were sent to the department heads and directors of graduate studies at each program in each discipline. Response rates were as follows: for the biological sciences, 21 percent of those surveyed responded; for chemistry, 30 percent; for computer science, 52 percent; for the earth sciences, 40 percent; for mathematics, 40 percent; and for physics, 39 percent.
Specialty rankings are based on nominations by department heads and directors of graduate studies at peer schools from the list of schools surveyed. These respondents ranked up to 10 programs in each area. Those with the most votes appear here.
http://www.usnews.com/usnews/edu/grad/r ... i_meth.php
Surveys in the biological sciences, chemistry, computer science, the earth sciences, mathematics, and physics were conducted by Synovate. The universe of schools surveyed consisted of schools that awarded at least five doctoral degrees according to the National Science Foundation report "Science and Engineering Doctorate Awards" for the years from 1999 through 2004. In the biological sciences, graduate programs may be offered in a university's medical school as well as its college of arts and sciences. In those cases, the medical school's program was considered separately.
Questionnaires were sent to the department heads and directors of graduate studies at each program in each discipline. Response rates were as follows: for the biological sciences, 21 percent of those surveyed responded; for chemistry, 30 percent; for computer science, 52 percent; for the earth sciences, 40 percent; for mathematics, 40 percent; and for physics, 39 percent.
Specialty rankings are based on nominations by department heads and directors of graduate studies at peer schools from the list of schools surveyed. These respondents ranked up to 10 programs in each area. Those with the most votes appear here.
http://www.usnews.com/usnews/edu/grad/r ... i_meth.php
"Physics is like sex. Sure, it may give some practical results, but that's not why we do it."
---R. Feynman ---
---R. Feynman ---
A чего обсуждать? И так известно что циферьки пованивают. Правда в прошлый раз когда я это сказал, про меня такие вещи говорили, я думал что на заседание в Раду попал.Cherep писал(а):Ну во-первых, эстетические чувства бурно возмутились не у "одного" пользователя, но это уже оффтопик.
Давайте обсудим происхождение Этих циферек.
"...Ohio Wesleyan University and St. John's College have not cooperated with the U.S. News rankings, and thus fell in the ratings. Conversely, for years, progressive Bard College did not cooperate with the U.S. News rankings, and thus saw its rankings artificially depressed; however, it now cooperates and consistently ranks numbers among the Top 40 liberal arts colleges...."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University ... f_rankings
Sometimes I do favors for people. They give me gifts.
-
powerblackout
I have no reason to believe they don't. Do you?powerblackout писал(а):do you really believe that those colleges deserve 1st rank?mitsu писал(а): "...Ohio Wesleyan University and St. John's College
Teбя не беспокоит что они вполне буквально говорят что органический химик из Гарварда будет получше органического химика из Scripps, намного лучше органического химика из UoC, а в UCSF - вообще не люди?
Sometimes I do favors for people. They give me gifts.
-
powerblackout
a ne nado vse ponimat' "bukval'no", В UCSF химия отстой, но советую посмотреть рейтинг биологических и медшкол. Главное что реитинг даёт примерное представление о местах. Кстати вот интересное наблюдение, полистайте Science И Nature, найдёте там удивительное совпадение, все статьи там в основном из мест первой тридцатки.mitsu писал(а): Teбя не беспокоит что они вполне буквально говорят что органический химик из Гарварда будет получше органического химика из Scripps, намного лучше органического химика из UoC, а в UCSF - вообще не люди?
Я например не Считаю что в Йове Стэйт идиоты а в Northwestern умники сидят. Просто первая двадцатка привлекает больше людей из за - оборудования, кто там faculty member, зарплата, и то место где находится универ (как правило большие города,индустриализованные области). А раз больше людей привлекаэтся соответственно больше выборка --->>> как следствие набирают действительно top 1% applicants)
powerblackout писал(а):
http://msnbc.msn.com/id/14321230/site/newsweek/
Here is our ranking:
1. Harvard University
2. Stanford University
3. Yale University
4. California Institute of Technology
5. University of California at Berkeley
6. University of Cambridge
7. Massachusetts Institute Technology
8. Oxford University
9. University of California at San Francisco
10. Columbia University
11. University of Michigan at Ann Arbor
12. University of California at Los Angeles
13. University of Pennsylvania
14. Duke University
15. Princeton Universitty
16. Tokyo University
17. Imperial College London
18. University of Toronto
19. Cornell University
20. University of Chicago
21. Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich
Я, конечно, извиняюсь, но зачем плодить монотопичные топики?
там они есть, только не в первой сотне,Tokashi писал(а):А рейтинга российских химических ВУзов у вас нет?
вот ссылка на то, как подобный рейтинг был рассчитан http://universitates.kharkov.ua/2004_4/moskovkin.htm
Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose
-
powerblackout
ммм...число покрашенных штативов?pH<7 писал(а):Посмотрите критерии оценки американских и ответьте мне на вопрос, на который я не знаю ответа:
а что мерять в росссийских ВУЗах?!
А если серьёзно, то единственное что можно мерять так это число уехавших и осевших за границей учёных.
Последний раз редактировалось powerblackout Пт авг 25, 2006 12:30 am, всего редактировалось 1 раз.
-
powerblackout
Кто сейчас на конференции
Сейчас этот форум просматривают: нет зарегистрированных пользователей и 11 гостей